Carnegie Holiday Cottage

Very Good
Traveller Type: Solo Traveler

Good
Traveller Type: Family with Young Children
  : Convenient location to town and amenities.
  : Carpets are getting a bit threadbare, struggle to open and close access doors, floor boards in hallway need fixing and shower facilities need to be improved. Suggest outside light for back door - stairs are lethal in the dark.

Good
Traveller Type: Family with Young Children
  : The location was very convenient and parking was easy. The living room was well furnished with a very comfortable suite and big dining table - and a huge TV if we had wanted it! Beds were also comfy and WiFi was generally good.
  : Shower was very small and it was difficult if not impossible to prevent leakage of water on to the floor - which seemed to be in a bad condition as a result. Front door was very stiff. Would also have appreciated some information/advice about bins and recycling.

Disappointing
Traveller Type: Family with Young Children
  : The cottage is outdated.

Poor
Traveller Type:
  : Shower tiny cubical no use for helping anyone shower hardly enough room ....photo taken from hallway ...overall decor of cottage poor...front and entry door very stiff ...some windows couldn't open painted over...door to garden dangerous although is marked as dangerous.....garden non starter....ant infestation in kitchen on one day ...wash machine not working ...did have use of one upstairs flat for 2 days out of 14...owner came to see but could not fix so gave us permission to use upstairs...wires everywhere ...TV Aries hung on window by piece of string...place clean ...windows dirty cobwebs ....kitchen no workspace...fridge old and not much space ... very 50's decor throughout....would be lovely if given a complete makeoner...Read reviews "after " holiday nothing much changed since 2019

Very Good
Traveller Type: Business Traveler

Disappointing
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : Key code but not easy to use.
  : N/A

Pleasant
Traveller Type: Business Traveler

Fair
Traveller Type: Traveling as Couple
  : The location is superb, close to the glen/ pittencrief park and high street, pubs, shops were a local stroll away, Food shopping like Tesco was walkable and Aldi a short drive. Ideally based to travel to Edinburgh , using Park and ride, and car journeys to aberdour, stirling and Loch ore were pleasant and no more than 10 -40 mins away.
  : The property needs updating, the garden could be a paradise if some money was spent on it. The windows were original but over painted so impossible to open some, There is little to no storage space in the kitchen. The furniture is very dated, like from the seventies. If the owner spent 10,000 updating the property it would be worth the 110 a night paid as it is a fairer figure would be more like 70, i holiday regularly in the uk and have stayed in far better accomodation for less money, So just some honest advice to the owner, speculate to accumulate, and you will rent it out more often.